Case study: Avoiding the 60% tax trap

Ellen is the chief executive of a design agency with an income of £125,000 p.a. in the current tax year.

At the moment she doesn’t make any pension contributions, but is attracted by the new flexibility she has read about online. She also feels that she is paying more Income Tax than expected and has asked EQ for help.

Ellen’s current income tax position

Ellen’s adjusted net income is more than £100,000 which means that her Personal Allowance (the part she pays no Income Tax on) will reduce by £1 for every £2 over this threshold. This means that Ellen’s Personal Allowance will reduce from £12,500 to nil (£25,000/2=£12,500).

Ellen pays Income Tax at 20% on the next £37,500 and £40% on the rest. The table below shows how her Income Tax is calculated.

  Income in this band Tax due
Personal Allowance @0% £0 £0
Basic Rate Band @ 20% £37,500 £7,500
Higher Rate Band @ 40% £87.500 £35,000
Total £125,000 £42,500

The £25,000 that Ellen earned over £100,000 has been taxed as follows:

  • 40% tax on the lost Personal Allowance (£12,500 x 40% = £5,000)
  • 40% tax on the £25,000 which is within the higher rate band (£25,000 x 40% = £10,000)

So this part of Ellen’s income is taxed at 60% (£15,000 tax on £25,000 income).

As Ellen earned more than £100,000 in the tax year it is also likely that HMRC will require her to complete a tax return.

Make a pension contribution

If Ellen makes a pension contribution of £20,000 net, before the end of the tax year, she could save this tax and make provision for her future retirement.

The contribution of £20,000 net will benefit from basic rate tax relief in her pension making it worth £25,000 (the gross amount). This reduces her ‘adjusted net income’ from £125,000 to £100,000 which means that she will get her Personal Allowance back. Not only this, but her Basic Rate Band will grow from £37,500 to £62,500.

As a result of paying £20,000 into her pension (which will immediately increase to £25,000) Ellen’s Income Tax will be calculated as follows:

  Income in this band Tax due
Personal Allowance @0% £12,500 £0
Basic Rate Band @ 20% £62,500 £12,500
Higher Rate Band @ 40% £50,000 £20,000
Total £125,000 £32,500

Ellen will pay £10,000 less Income Tax and gain £5,000 within her pension following her contribution; she has effectively received 60% tax relief on her contribution!

When Ellen completes her tax return, she will be able to regain her personal allowance and claim higher rate tax relief on her pension contributions.

» If you require any further clarity on any of the points raised above, please do not hesitate to get in touch.